7 Apr 1914
Al McCoy beats George Chip via knockout 1/10
Middleweight (160 lb)
Al McCoy becomes the IBU and NYSAC Middleweight world champion
6 Apr 1915
George Chip beats Al McCoy via newspaper decision 10/10
4 May 1915
Jimmy Clabby beats Al McCoy via newspaper decision 10/10
31 May 1915
Al McCoy and Silent Martin share a draw 10/10
9 Sep 1915
Young Ahearn beats Al McCoy via newspaper decision 10/10
25 Nov 1915
Silent Martin beats Al McCoy via newspaper decision 15/15
1 Jan 1916
14 Nov 1917
Mike O'Dowd beats Al McCoy via knockout 6/10